Comparing Roofing Materials in Lancaster, PA: Asphalt, Metal, Slate & More

Comparing Roofing Materials in Lancaster, PA: Asphalt, Metal, Slate & More

How to Pick the Best Roofing Material for Your Home

If you’ve realized it’s time to replace your roof, you may be wondering if you should stick with asphalt shingles or explore other materials like slate, clay, or metal. Every roofing material comes with its own pros and cons, from cost and durability to aesthetics and maintenance. Knowing these differences will help you make an informed decision — one that protects your Lancaster or Chester County home for decades to come.

At Best Contracting, we’ve installed thousands of roofs throughout Southeastern Pennsylvania. Here’s a complete guide to the most popular roofing options available today.

Key Factors to Consider When Choosing a Roof

Before comparing roofing materials, think about your home’s needs and your personal preferences. Our full guide on how to choose a new roof dives deeper, but here are the main considerations:

• Longevity: How long will the roof last?
• Durability: Can it handle Pennsylvania’s snow, wind, and hail?
• Weight: Does your structure need reinforcement for heavy materials?
• Aesthetics: Will it match your siding, gutters, and overall curb appeal?
• Cost: Does the price — including installation — fit your budget?
• Maintenance: How much upkeep does it require?
• Home Value: Will it increase resale value?

Asphalt Shingles: The Most Common Choice

Asphalt shingles remain the most popular roofing material in Lancaster County because they balance affordability, durability, and ease of installation.

Pros:

• Affordable and widely available.
• Simple installation by certified contractors.
• Available in many colors and styles.
• Fire-resistant.

Cons:

• Not suitable for flat roofs.
• Typically lasts 20–25 years — less than slate or metal.

Wood Shakes: Natural Beauty With Maintenance Needs

Wood roofing, often cedar shakes, offers a rustic and timeless look. It’s lighter than slate or clay, but it does require ongoing maintenance.

Pros:

• Warm, natural appearance that enhances curb appeal.
• All-natural materials.
• Lighter than many alternatives.
• Can be treated to resist fire.

Cons:

• Requires treatments to resist mold, mildew, and fire.
• Durability depends on climate and wood type.
• Restricted in some municipalities due to fire codes.

Metal Roofing: Durable and Long-Lasting

Metal roofing is becoming increasingly popular across Chester and Berks Counties thanks to its durability and energy efficiency. Options include steel, aluminum, copper, and zinc alloys.

Pros:

• Lasts 40–70 years with proper care.
• Variety of colors and finishes.
• Excellent resistance to fire, wind, and pests.
• Energy-efficient — reflects heat and reduces cooling bills.
• Boosts home value.

Cons:

• Higher upfront cost.
• Requires specialized installation.
• Copper will patina (turn green) over time.

Clay Tile Roofing: Mediterranean Style

Clay tiles are ideal for stucco homes and offer a distinctive Italian or Spanish look. While durable, they are heavy and expensive to install.

Pros:

• Timeless, Mediterranean aesthetic.
• Resistant to fire, rot, and insects.
• Very long lifespan.

Cons:

• Heavy — may require roof reinforcement.
• High material and installation costs.
• More maintenance required than other materials.

Slate Roofing: The Gold Standard

Slate roofing is one of the most durable and prestigious materials on the market. It’s ideal for homeowners seeking longevity and classic beauty.

Pros:

• Can last 75–100 years with proper care.
• All-natural, environmentally friendly material.
• Resistant to fire, wind, and mold.
• Enhances curb appeal and resale value.

Cons:

• High upfront cost.
• Very heavy — roof reinforcement is often required.
• Not suitable for flat roofs.

Roofing FAQs for Lancaster & Chester County Homeowners

Which roofing material lasts the longest?

Slate and metal roofing have the longest lifespans — often 50+ years. Asphalt is the most affordable but typically lasts 20–25 years.

Can I install a new roof in winter?

Yes, but installation requires the right conditions. Contact Best Contracting to learn about scheduling during colder months.

Is metal roofing noisy during storms?

Not when installed properly. With solid underlayment and insulation, metal roofs are no louder than asphalt shingles.

Will a new roof increase my home value?

Yes. According to industry reports, a new roof can return up to 60–70% of its cost in resale value while boosting curb appeal.

Serving Homeowners Across Southeastern PA

Lancaster, PA

From asphalt roof replacements to premium slate installations, our Lancaster crews deliver roofs designed for Pennsylvania’s unique climate.

Chester County

Whether you’re in West Chester or Glenmoore, we specialize in storm-damage repairs and long-lasting replacements tailored to Chester County homes.

Reading & Berks County

In Berks County, our team installs gutters alongside new roofing systems to keep homes protected from water damage year-round.

Need Help Choosing the Best Roofing Material?

A roof replacement doesn’t have to be stressful. Choosing a trusted, certified contractor makes all the difference. Best Contracting is fully insured, holds multiple roofing certifications, and backs every project with a 10-year workmanship warranty.

If you’re ready to explore your options for asphalt, metal, slate, or other roofing materials, request a free quote today. We’ll help you choose the perfect roof for your home in Lancaster, Chester, Berks, or the surrounding areas.