Repair, Patch, or Replace Your Roof – Which One Is Best For You?

If you’ve traced the source of a leak to your roof, you may think you need to replace your whole roof. For minor roof damage, however, you may only need to patch or replace a few shingles. On the other hand, it could be a sign it’s time for a roof replacement. But how can you know which option is best for you?

Your options will depend on aesthetics, your budget, and the extent of the damage. Let’s explore how to know whether to repair, patch, or replace your roof.

Should you repair your roof?

Hail storms or strong winds can often cause damage significant enough to need repairs. Homeowners should consider roof repair if they notice red flags indicating the roof has sustained some damage or normal wear and tear.

Here are some signs your roof needs repair:

  • Leaky roof
  • Shingles are curling, missing, or broken
  • Shingle granules in the gutter
  • Daylight showing through the roof
  • Higher than usual energy bills

Repairs are often more affordable than replacing the whole roof. It may also be more environmentally friendly to do regular maintenance and repairs rather than replacing the roof when you spot signs of damage.

However, sometimes it’s difficult to match new shingles with the color of the rest of the roof. You may end up with a slightly off-colored shingle replacement, especially if your current roof is a bit older. Having two different shades of roofing may affect your overall curb appeal.

Should you patch your roof?

Patching is for smaller repairs to your roof. Often the damage is focused on one tiny area, and patching could help fix the issue. However, it’s essential to ensure the damage hasn’t spread to other areas of your roof. Sometimes underlying issues are hard to notice, and a roofing professional can check the quality of your entire roof.

Patching your roof is less labor-intensive, which is part of why it’s the most affordable option. It’s more cost-effective than replacing a roof. When done correctly, a roof patch can fix a leak or replace a shingle. Patches are only an option if the damage is minor, so it’s imperative for homeowners to conduct regular roofing inspections and catch problems early.

Should you replace your roof?

Out of all your options, roof replacement is the most expensive. However, it’s also your best choice if your roof is significantly damaged or has gone through its lifespan.

While a roof replacement is a large project, roofing contractors can handle it efficiently and return your home to you as soon as possible. Hiring roofing contractors also means they can expertly inspect your roof to identify any underlying issues.

When you invest in quality roofing materials, your new roof can last for decades. This means you save money in the long term by not needing to replace it again in the near future. It helps if homeowners conduct regular roof inspections to catch minor problems early and treat them immediately.

Still unsure? Get a roof inspection

A roof is one of the most essential parts of your home. Without a functional roof, homes face water damage, mold, and other structural issues. Fixing problems with a roof should be remedied quickly to prevent your home from deteriorating.

At Best Contracting, we pride ourselves on being roofing contractors you can trust in the Lancaster, PA region. If you want a roofing inspection or find your roof needs repairs, don’t hesitate to call us at 888-857-4124 or fill out our online form to request a free quote.

Share this article